Home

What Is the Third Estate

What Is the Third Estate

 

 

What Is the Third Estate

 
Abbe Sieyes   -   sE-"A-'yes
What Is the Third Estate?
1789

Background

Although in 1788 King Louis XVI (r. 1771-1792) agreed to call the Estates General, he left a thorny procedural question for the deputies to answer; would the assembly vote by order or by head?  The debate over this question galvanized the nation in the months preceding the opening of the Estates General in May 1789, thanks in part to pamphlets like the one that follows.  Written by a middle-class clergyman, Abbe Emmanuel-Joseph Sieyes (1748-1836), this pamphlet’s message was clear: the privileged few should not determine the nation’s future, as a traditional vote by order would ensure by allowing the clergy and nobility to join forces to block any decision contrary to their liking.  Rather, government should rest in the hands of the people who labor and skills sustain society, the Third Estate.  In forging his argument, Sieyes forcefully condemned traditional political and social structures while granting the Their Estate a voice on the national state.

  The plan of this book is fairly simple. We must ask ourselves three questions.

  1. What is the Third State? Everything.

  2. What has it been until now in the political order? Nothing.

  3. What does it want to be? Something....

All individual efforts may be included in for classes:
1. Since the earth and the waters furnish crude products for the needs of man, the first class, in logical sequence, will be that of all families which devote themselves to agricultural labor.

2. Between the first sale of products and their consumption or use, a new manipulation, more or less repeated, adds to these products a second value more or less composite. In this manner human industry succeeds in perfecting the gifts of nature, and the crude product increases two-fold, ten-fold, one hundred-fold in value. Such are the efforts of the second class.

3. Between production and consumption, as well as between the various stages of production, a group of intermediary agents establish themselves, useful both to producers and consumer; these are the merchants and brokers: the brokers who, comparing incessantly the demands of time and place, speculate upon the profit of retention and transportation; merchants who are charged with distribution, in the last analysis, either at wholesale or at retail. This species of utility characterizes the third class.

4. Outside of these three classes of productive and useful citizens, who are occupied with real objects of consumption and use, there is also need in a society of a series of efforts and pains, whose objects are directly useful or agreeable to the individual. This fourth class embraces all those who stand between the most distinguished and liberal professions and the less esteemed services of domestics.
Such are the efforts which sustain society. Who puts them forth? The Third Estate.
[Public Functions]
Public functions may be classified equally well, in the present state of affairs, under four recognized heads; the sword, the robe, the church and the administration. It would be superfluous to take them up one by one, for the purpose of showing that everywhere the Third Estate attends to nineteen-twentieths of them, with this distinction; that it is laden with all that which is really painful, with all the burdens which the privileged classes refuse to carry. Do we give the Third Estate credit for this? That this might come about, it would be necessary that the Third Estate should refuse to fill these places, or that it should be less ready to exercise their functions. The facts are well known. Meanwhile they have dared to impose a prohibition upon the order of the Third Estate. They have said to it: "Whatever may be your services, whatever may be your abilities, you shall go thus far; you may not pass beyond!"
It suffices here to have made it clear that the pretended utility of a privileged order for the public service is nothing more than a chimera; that with it all that which is burdensome in this service is performed by the Third Estate; that without it the superior places would be infinitely better filled; that they naturally ought to be the lot and the recompense of ability and recognized services, and that if privileged persons have come to usurp all the lucrative and honorable posts, it is a hateful injustice to the rank and file of citizens and at the same a treason to the public.
Who then shall dare to say that the Third Estate has not within itself all that is necessary for the formation of a complete nation? It is the strong and robust man who has one arm still shackled. If the privileged order should be abolished, the nation would be nothing less, but something more. Therefore, what is the Third Estate? Everything; but an everything shackled and oppressed. What would it be without the privileged order? Everything, but an everything free and flourishing. Nothing can succeed without it, everything would be infinitely better without the others.
The Third Estate embraces then all that which belongs to the nation; and all that which is not the Third Estate, cannot be regarded as being of the nation.
What is the Third Estate?
It is everything!
By Third Estate is meant the collectively of citizens who belong to the common order.  Anybody who holds a legal privilege of any kind leaves that common order, stands as an exception to the common law, and in consequence does not belong to the Third Estate…It is certain that the moment a citizen acquires privileges contrary to common law, he no longer belongs to the common order.  His new interest is opposed to the general interest; he has no right to vote in the name of the people…
What is the will of a Nation? It is the result of individual wills, just as the Nation is the aggregate of the individuals who compose it.  It is impossible to conceive of a legitimate association that does not have for its goal the common security, the common liberty, in short, the public good.  No doubt each individual also has his own personal aims.  He says to himself, “protected by the common security, I will be able to peacefully pursue my own personal projects, I will seek my happiness where I will, assured of encountering only those legal obstacles that society will prescribe for the common interest, in which I have a part and with which my own personal interest is so usefully allied.”…
Advantages which differentiate citizens from one another lie outside the purview of citizenship.  Inequalities of wealth or ability are like the inequalities of age, six, size, etc.  In no way do they detract from the equality of citizenship.  These individual advantages no doubt benefit from the protection of the law; but it is not the legislator’s talk to create them, to give privileges to some and refuse them to others.  The law grants nothing; it protects what already exists until such time that what exists begins to harm the common interest.  These are the only limits on individual freedom.  I imagine the law as being at the center of a large globe; we the citizens, without exception, stand equidistant from it on the surface and occupy equal places; all are equally dependent on the law, all present it with their liberty and their property to be protected; and this is what I call the common rights of citizens, by which they are all alike.  All these individuals communicate with each other, enter into contracts, negotiate, always under the common guarantee of the law.  If in this general activity somebody wishes to get control over the person of his neighbor or usurp his property, the common law goes into action to repress this criminal attempt and puts everyone back in their place at the same distance from the law…
It is impossible to say what place the two privileged orders ought to occupy in the social order:  this is the equivalent of asking what place one wished to assign to a malignant tumor that torments and undermines the strength of the body of a sick person.  It must be neutralized.  We must re-establish the health and working of all the organs so thoroughly that they are no longer susceptible to these fatal schemes that are capable of sapping the most essential principles of vitality.

Questions:

  1. What is the traditional status of the Third Estate?  How does Sieyes want to change it, and why?
  2. Why do you think Sieyes was so critical of nobility in particular?  What do these criticisms reveal about his political principles?
  3. How effective do you think this pamphlet is as a work of political propaganda, and why?

------

 

Source: https://lps.org/manila/tbayne/3rdEstateSieyes.doc

Web site to visit: https://lps.org

Author of the text: indicated on the source document of the above text

If you are the author of the text above and you not agree to share your knowledge for teaching, research, scholarship (for fair use as indicated in the United States copyrigh low) please send us an e-mail and we will remove your text quickly. Fair use is a limitation and exception to the exclusive right granted by copyright law to the author of a creative work. In United States copyright law, fair use is a doctrine that permits limited use of copyrighted material without acquiring permission from the rights holders. Examples of fair use include commentary, search engines, criticism, news reporting, research, teaching, library archiving and scholarship. It provides for the legal, unlicensed citation or incorporation of copyrighted material in another author's work under a four-factor balancing test. (source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_use)

The information of medicine and health contained in the site are of a general nature and purpose which is purely informative and for this reason may not replace in any case, the council of a doctor or a qualified entity legally to the profession.

 

What Is the Third Estate

 

The texts are the property of their respective authors and we thank them for giving us the opportunity to share for free to students, teachers and users of the Web their texts will used only for illustrative educational and scientific purposes only.

All the information in our site are given for nonprofit educational purposes

 

What Is the Third Estate

 

 

Topics and Home
Contacts
Term of use, cookies e privacy

 

What Is the Third Estate